“ A3 course meal with many options to choose from for less than $20 pp, the serving sizes are huge, you'll beg for more bread because it's that good and our server Caesar was amazing. Always a hit for us. ”

“ There's something about Mary's Pizza!! The vodka grandma slice w/ the sesame seed crust is definitely a keeper!!! ”

“ So I've been to this particular location a little over a year ago. And the food was insane. I actually got put onto Mary's by going to their out east location. I believe it's considered Eastport. Either way after having that, it set my expectations for Farmingdale the first time. However, this time is a little bit different. I'm not sure if they changed owners, but everything was not quite the same as my first try. For appetizers we got the mini rice balls which were crispy on the outside soggy in the inside which they isn't far off but very, very salty. We also got the fried mozzarella, but the sauce was very bitter. The dinner came out and it was Huge portions, which you can't complain about. the only thing I could say I didn't like was the Alfredo sauce on my spaghetti it had a bit of a burnt taste if that makes sense. Other than that cordon bleu changed a little from the normal presentation but still great. My girl bowl of pasta that will last for a week, she is thrilled. ”

“ Self proclaimed Pizza Snob here...was working in the area and finally got to stop in at this place. Had heard a couple of good things about it and rightfully so. First off, they have a very nice selection of "specialty" slices but I went for the regular slice because, if that's bad, the rest probably aren't good either. Thankfully, this is a very good slice! The sauce is very tasty, not sweet, and the cheese isn't chewy or too "melty". The crust is very good with the right mix of crisp and foldability. This is a very solid slice! Well worth a return trip! ”

“ Really good bbq slice and chicken bacon ranch. Their knots are fire too. Super underrated pizzeria. They really dont disappoint ”

“ Although the food is consistently good, the staff has proven not to be as consistently warm and friendly. It makes me uncomfortable to ask questions or for items that they have forgotten to give me...ie, water, bread, refills, etc... ”

“ Have you heard the buzz about the "Too good to go" App? Anyway it's a great concept. The restaurant will list surprise bags at a discount and at the end of the day you go get your bag! Not good for anyone with allergies or dietary restrictions as you can't choose what you get. But it's great to prevent food from going to waste, and helping local businesses at the same time. I stumbled upon Mary's pizza. I've been to other locations and I know that's good. I reserved my surprise and I got a bunch of different items! I got a Mac and cheese slice, bbq chicken slice, veggie slice, eggplant sandwich, 4 fried Mac and cheese balls, 3 garlic knots and 5 zeppoles! All for $5.99!! A great deal, and no waste! I currently only ate the bbq slice, a Mac and cheese ball and a garlic knot at it was delicious!!! So much flavor and fresh! I have atleast another two meals plus dessert! Service was also very friendly! Don't forget to tip! Although you are getting a discount, tipping is always appreciated. I would absolutely return and pay full price any day. ***** ”